That is the most recent in our One Photograph sequence, the place PhotoShelter photographers share their most significant photograph and the story behind it.  Additionally watch our One Photograph video right here, the place 5 photographers inform us what their picture means to them. 

His identify is Mike Pinay. He’s a First Nations Canadian who was despatched to the Qu’Appelle Indian Residential College in Canada for 10 years between the ages of six and 16. Immediately, this portrait of Mike is photographer Daniella Zalcman’s one photograph: 

Mike Pinay, pictured above, attended the Qu’Appelle Indian Residential College from 1953 to 1963. © Daniella Zalcman

“It was the worst ten years of my life,” Mike recalled. “How do you find out about relationships? How do you find out about household? I didn’t even know what love was.”

Residential colleges had been a century-long establishment in Canada. The federal government would take younger Indigenous kids from their houses and relocate them to boarding colleges. There, the youngsters had been pressured to assimilate to Western society, and so they had been punished — usually bodily  — for exhibiting any indicators of their very own tradition. Hundreds died whereas within the system and the final faculty lastly closed in 1996.

This picturesque little village is Lebret, Saskatchewan — house to the Qu’Appelle Indian Residential College, which operated underneath the federal authorities and Catholic Church from 1884-1969, and underneath the governance of the Star Blanket Cree Nation from 1973-1998. Whereas many of the unique faculty constructions have been demolished, one constructing stays, seen on the far proper aspect of the photograph. © Daniella Zalcman

Daniella met Mike at some point after embarking on a mission analyzing elevated HIV charges in Canada’s Indigenous communities. “I noticed that each individual I interviewed who was HIV constructive and First Nations had additionally gone via residential faculty,” she mentioned. “I’d by no means even heard of this technique, and I wished to study extra.”

A swingset in Beauval, Saskatchewan, close to the previous web site of the Beauval Indian Residential College. © Daniella Zalcman

Many of the unique residential faculty buildings have been destroyed, however this one —as soon as Muskowekwan Indian Residential College — remains to be standing, and was even used as an administrative workplace constructing for a number of years. Now, the constructing is basically in ruins. This piano could also be one of many solely surviving relics from when the constructing was a faculty. © Daniella Zalcman

Mike advised Daniella about his painful lack of tradition, together with the lack of his identify. “Whereas there, Mike was often called a quantity — No. 73,” mentioned Daniella. “This speaks to the deep degree of dehumanization that went on within the system.”

A lot of Mike’s day was dedicated to the maintenance of the college itself, together with farming, taking good care of livestock, cooking, and cleansing. There was no math or historical past class, and the youngsters had been nearer to indentured servants than they had been college students. Church providers had been additionally necessary, and sometimes required every day.  

After leaving, Mike went via an extended journey to reclaim his id. “Most of my dialog with Mike centered round what it means to heal from the trauma of cultural genocide — and for him, and lots of different First Nations Canadians, that required a return to his Indigenous language, tradition, and traditions as an grownup,” mentioned Daniella.

The one highway from Beauval Indian Residential College (at the least 50+ years in the past, on the darkest level within the faculty’s historical past), led straight to the Beaver River. College students usually tried to run away, however both had been too small to attempt to cross or drowned within the try. © Daniella Zalcman

“It’s a sophisticated and painful course of to re-learn the issues that ought to have been a part of your childhood, however lots of the residential faculty survivors I met appeared to have discovered a well beyond their experiences and develop deep connections to their First Nations id.”

Mike’s expertise and tales like his impressed Daniella to shift gears. A mission she initially entered from a public well being perspective was now in regards to the id of Indigenous folks.

She determined to a sequence of composite portraits as a result of she believed these tales had been about each reminiscence and trauma, and he or she wished each facets represented.

“Every certainly one of these portraits, together with this picture, is of a residential faculty survivor superimposed with a picture that represents their recollections and experiences in class,” she mentioned. 

Gary Edwards attended the Ile-a-la-Crosse Indian Residential College from 1970 to 1973, St. Michael’s Indian Residential College from 1974 to 1976, and Qu’Appelle Indian Residential College from 1976 to 1978. © Daniella Zalcman

Daniella shot the whole sequence along with her iPhone. She had initially meant to on medium format movie, however the want for imagery felt extra rapid. “I wished to create a number of exposures on the highway as a substitute of ready weeks or months to get my pictures again from the darkroom,” she mentioned.

Immediately, the composite portrait of Mike, along with the others, carry great that means for Daniella. “This mission helped me work out methods to inform tales another way,” she mentioned. “It might not be fully mainstream, however for me it’s a extra trustworthy and truthful approach to current these people.”  

Deedee Lerat attended the Marieval Indian Residential College from 1967 to 1970. © Daniella Zalcman

© Daniella Zalcman

This sequence, titled Indicators of Your Identification, has taught Daniella that storytelling is difficult as a result of producing empathy is troublesome.

“I feel we stay in a world the place folks eat extra imagery than ever,” she mentioned. “On one hand, that is unbelievable. Alternatively, it’s terrifying. It means we’ve develop into desensitized to a lot human struggling and ache.”

“The reality is, there are solely so many pictures of a lifeless Syrian baby you may take a look at earlier than you cease feeling.”

To Daniella, at this time’s problem in visible journalism is to determine methods to make folks cease and really feel. It’s one thing she believes we’re all battling at this very second, and the issue has opened an area for various types of pictures.

“We’ve got a accountability to reframe how folks take into consideration present occasions and social points.”

“Within the West, we consider that we’re higher outfitted to inform tales of Indigenous communities than the folks themselves,” mentioned Daniella. “I consider that is categorically unfaithful. In a great future world, we’ll empower folks to inform their very own tales. I consider that proper now, I’m an imperfect completely satisfied medium.”

Valerie Ewenin, who attended the Muskowekwan Indian Residential College from 1965 to 1971. © Daniella Zalcman

Immediately, this photograph of Mike Pinay reminds Daniella to reframe how tales are advised. “We proceed to marginalize and omit plenty of histories of individuals of colour, each in our textbooks and mainstream media,” she mentioned. “This mission is my small try and appropriate that.”


What’s your one photograph? E mail onephoto@ together with your picture and some sentences telling us what it means to you.* We’ll decide our favorites to share.

*We strongly help your rights as a photographer. We is not going to use your pictures with out your permission, and we declare no business rights to them.